Ask Your Question

Angie's List Answers is the trusted spot to ask home improvement and health questions and get answers from service companies, health providers and consumers. For ratings and reviews on companies in your area, search Angie's List.

 
 
or
Top 30 Days Experts
Rank Leader Points*
1 LCD 8720
2 Member Services 6040
3 ContractorDon 1205
4 Jefferson 345
5 BayAreaAC 345
6 the new window man 245
7 SalisburySam 160
8 sooty 160
9 Roofman1 150
10 SmartEnergyToday 120

*Updates every 4 hours

Browse Projects By Category

Question DetailsAsked on 4/3/2012

Is it customary to tip workmen, such as plumbers, electricians, remodelers, etc.? I've never heard of tipping contactors.

Recently, I read something on Angie's List about tipping on the full value of the deal, not just on the amount paid. I understand that if it is a massage, beauty salon service, or something similar, but not household repairs or other types of workers.

Do you have the same question? Follow this Question


10 Answers

Voted Best Answer
8
Votes

From the wall street journal online:

"Etiquette and tipping experts agree that tipping a contractor and his employees isn't expected because contractors offer to do a job for you at a specific price. Any extra money they would want would be built into their bid. Also, it's a business relationship rather than one where they are performing a personal service for you like a waiter or a maid. But if the employees do extra jobs around the house, then experts say it is appropriate to tip a cash amount equivalent to the task; "tip gifts" such as cookies and drinks can count. "The key to tipping is whether or not it was outside the scope of what was normally expected," says Mark Brenner, author of "Tipping for Success!"

My opinion is that a little bit of courtesy (snacks, drinks, expression of appreciation etc.) goes a long way and upon completion of their work you feel compelled by a job well done to offer a little extra in the form of a tip - go for it, but do not feel obligated.

Source: http://hmdhome.com/boston-design-cent...

Answered 2 years ago by HMDhome

0
Votes

I live in NYC and do tip employee plumbers, air conditioner installers, appliance repairmen, if they are on time, polite and do a good job. This is important if I know I will use them again. Usually the crew chief gets the tip and it's up to him to share. Contractors and self employed workers
(like my single electrician) don't get tips.

Answered 2 years ago by Guest_9928650

4
Votes

As a General Contractor for 20 years in California, I see one large problem giving cash to employees of a contractor. Under EDD guidelines, when you give money to someone for work done, that is not a legal independent contractor, they become your employee. There is a good chance that they could file an injury claim against the homeowner. We have received "tips" for extra effort which we pass on to the employees, since our pay is part of the contract. Since our Diamond Certified reputation is due to the work of our employees and subcontractors, it behooves us to treat them as well as possible.

Answered 2 years ago by Cline1

-1
Votes

Having owned an A?C contracting company since 1975, i can tell that somee customers tip our techs and installers very well,but is not expected for them to make a good living, like a food server. So I'd just go with my personal feeling.

We have done to major renovations at our the past two years, I tipped all the workers with a Free Air Conditioning Cleaning and Tune-up,since I know our guys appreciate it when they get tipped.

Source: http://www.bayareacool.com

Answered 2 years ago by BayAreaAC

1
Vote

It depends. If they do an excellent job and are really great - it's up to you. If they are out working in 95 degree weather, water, soda are Greatly appreciated. And under these conditions tips are suggested. Some industries, like Movers generally expect a tip, and is usually suggested in the paper work.


If someone/crew goes above and beyond it is always greatly appreciated.


Many peoply let they're dogs out just when the crew is sitting down out side to work, some never offer to let them use their bath room eventhough the crew is there 9 hours.


"contractors" is a very broad term and varies by locality - like NYC. If not sure, simply ask the foremen/supervisor what the custom is. They won't lie and most will say no. Repeating my self, above and beyond or unusually circumstances warrent a tip.

-Brenda

Answered 2 years ago by help1968

1
Vote

You don't have to tip your contractor, it's really not expected, but remember we are people too. If you expect the guys to be on your job for a few days, a little lunch and coffee now and again will go a loooooooong way!



As the owner of my company I have only been tipped once, not counting lunches and what not, my guys have been tipped a few times each year. If you are gonig to tip, just tip the workers directly.

Source: http://www.reliableamerican.us

Answered 2 years ago by ReliableAmericanRoof

0
Votes

Never. As a contractor I would NOT want people to tip my employees. Additionally over the years I have recieved 'tips' from customers that when they paid added an additional hundred dollars or so. I have not returned that money and we invested it back into our company, but tipping is something I would not want people to do. Make/Buy a lunch, provide cold drinks or snacks would be great and appreciated. But NO tipping


APA Paint

Answered 1 year ago by APAPaint

1
Vote

I would not want anyone tipping my employees or subcontractors. And believe me it is not expected.

Source: I am a construction estimator

Answered 12 months ago by Guest_9388144

-2
Votes

I think it is customary to tip. But, what each person tips is up to them. In our business we have several customers that tip in different ways. For instance we had one lady that had us replace a door knob, fix a leaking faucet, put up 3 shelves in her garage, move a couch, fix her garbage disposal and replace some trim on one side of her house around a window. We charged her $100.00. She appologized because she had no money to give us a tip until pay day which was two days away. My husband told her that she already gave us a tip which was the sodas. He offered half of the money back, due to her not having money until pay day. She said if she needed anything she would call her son.Then other times we get a tip of cash, for instance last week we received a $400.00 tip. We have received higher amounts that this as well as a car once. But the point is whether it is a glass of water, a thank you, a lamp they no longer need and yes we have received a few over the years among other things, including the car. It does not always have to be cash in order to be a tip. But, no matter what you receive as a tip show appreciation. Even when it comes to most of the lamps we could not use over the years. We have always found some one that could use the item(s). It's treat people the way you want to be treated, and always show appreciation.

Answered 6 months ago by flandershomeservice

1
Vote

As someone who has always been the worker not the owner,if anybody does a good job,whats wrong with giving a tip?I dont think thiers much case law for personal injury for giving a tip.

Answered 3 months ago by Guest_98356521

2
Votes

As a general contractor for 40 years, I do not want my employees cash tripped. I do however, strongly urge my clients to provide occasional pizza, sodas...etc to show their appreciation, which in turn gets the best out of our employees and subcontractors. Michael Kavin

Answered 3 months ago by Guest_9406809




Related Questions