Ask Your Question

Angie's List Answers is the trusted spot to ask home improvement and health questions and get answers from service companies, health providers and consumers. For ratings and reviews on companies in your area, search Angie's List.

 
 
or
Top 30 Days Experts
Rank Leader Points*
1 LCD 3655
2 kstreett 240
3 Guest_9020487 110
4 Guest_9190926 105
5 ahowell 95
6 KnowledgeBase 95
7 skbloom 80
8 Guest_98024861 70
9 Guest_9311297 70
10 Guest_9400529 70

*Updates every 4 hours

Browse Projects By Category

Question DetailsAsked on 3/12/2015

is it ok to install a new roof while it is raining? Would wet felt paper or moisture under the shingles cause probl

New roof installation on new construction. OSB sheathing, 15# felt, asphalt shingles

Do you have the same question? Follow this Question


2 Answers

0
Votes

What really causes problems is repetitive/continual moisture. Especially on new construction, the materials will dry. It would have been great if they had the decking covered before it rained. But rain on the decking then roofing done as long as the roof is leak free now, you should be fine. It is more important on remodeling as the interior may get damaged, but on new construction the whole home will be drying out.

Answered 2 years ago by ExteriorUpgrader

1
Vote

The NRCA (National Roofing Contractors and Manufacturers Association) Roofing Manuals, Construction Specifications Institute, standard federal construction standards from various agencies, and InternationResidential Building Code (used by most states) all prohibit placing either the water barrier membrane or shingles over wet substrate.



The decking (sheathing) should have been tarped and work stopped as soon as it was evident enough rain was going to fall to wet the wood or water barrier (felt). Having wet sheathing covered with tarpaper or membrane will trap the water in the sheathing - very bad practice and contrary to industry standardss for roofing. As the other comment said, with normal exterior rated plywood one wetting, assuming your attic is well enough ventilated to dry the wood out in a few days, is probably not going to cause much damage to the sheathing. OSB is another matter - a lousy material for roofing or exterior sheathing for that matter, in my opinion, because when it gets wet it starts swelling and falling apart much like particle board, just a bit slower, resulting in mildew or mold in it (or rot if it stays wet for extended period of time), and also get rough surfaced as the pieces expand, which can reflect through the shingle roofing and also can cause tearing and perforation of the water resistant membrane when the workers walk on it putting the shingles on.



The felt, if it is wet when the shingles are applied, will invariably bulge and crease if not outright tear under the workers feet (or bulge/crease just by being wet in many cases) which can also reflect through to the shingle surface as bulges and waves. There are several nightmare cases a year or two ago in the Home > Roofing section of Browse Projects about that.



In a 1-2 day reroof this can be a tough situation, because the contractor will say it will all level out over time, and of course by the time you have paid for the job and it becomes obvious it will not level out, his warranty period has gone by or he blames it on the shingles or subsequent weather or whatever. With new construction you have more time to watch it to see if any bulges or waves flatten out as the house is built before final acceptance, but if you do not note the issue to the builder and take issue with wet surface roofing as it is going on (or as soon as you learn of it) and get it on the record that you consider that substandard construction, then if you do end up with a wavy or rippled roof surface it will be way too late to get satisfaction for it.



You also run the risk of manufacturer warranties being voided by the roofing materials being put over wet surfaces, or being applied in the rain.



How aggressively you take this up with the contractor is your call, but it is your house and you are not paying him for substandard work. However, raising this issue this relatively early in the job will also tend to sour the relationship for the rest of the job - not right, but it happens.



This is another instance of shoddy workmanship like you see all the time - probably the reason only about 10-15% of AL listed vendors are recommended, and the rest are considered "stay away from" cases. Issues like this crop up all the time - also pouring concrete without cold/hot weather protection during or when sub-45 or over 95 degree temps are expected within 7 days, houses standing framed without roof or exterior housewrap or siding for many months, window and door rough openings being left unprotected for months, plumbing and electrical and even HVAC equipment going in before houses are "closed in", basements and crawlspaced allowed to fill with water, etc. It is a far cry from the "good old days" when building inspectors actually (usually) did thorough inspections at several stages of the work progress, and most contractors did professional work - these days, you go on a jobsite and your eye is constantly drawn to incorrectly or sloppily done work.



One alternative would be to document it, and get the contractor to include a 1 year WRITTEN no-charge replacement warranty against any distortion, bulging, waves, or other noticeable deformation of the finished roof surface for 1 year from closing date on the house. Then whether it is torn off and done right or they cross their fingers is between the roof sub and the GC.



In summary,as soon as you saw them roofing in the rain, had you known then answer at that time, that would have been the time to call the GC on the issue.

Answered 2 years ago by LCD




Related Questions


Terms Of Use
|
Privacy Policy